How to Toast a Bagel in the Oven?

Is your toaster broken? The following instructions will show you how to toast a bagel in the oven.

Bagels are chewy, soft, and delicious, and they make a fantastic breakfast sandwich when packed high with smoked salmon, capers, and onions.

How about an obscenely large, beautiful rainbow bagel from that little NYC bakery?

Even these are left over the next day to be consumed.

How to Toast a Bagel in the OvenBagels are flexible, hearty, and a clean slate just waiting for some of your best toppings, whether they’re toasted or fresh from the bakery, grabbed from your Thomas’ Bagels bag or the Lender’s Bagels rack at the store.

Bagels from your favourite bakery or straight from the bag need to be resurrected in a way that preserves their flavour.

We’ll go through some of the best methods to toast bagels so they stay delicious, crispy, chewy, and fresh.

If you are wondering how to toast a bagel in the oven, then look no further than this article. In case of an un-toasted one with moisture still on it (or if they’re just too soft), take out as many rounds from their centres before putting them into your heated pan this will make sure that everything cooks evenly and gets crispier faster!

Preheat your oven or a toaster oven 375°F for at least 4-5 minutes before putting the bagel in it. If you have one that’s been stored correctly, after cooking there will be an awesome chewy interior and crispy crust of browned bread on top!

Another option is to toast the bagel whole by immersing it in boiling water. This process includes manufacturing the bagel again while it is dry and stale. This approach does not provide the same crispiness as a traditional bagel, but it is a simple option for dry bagels.

Should You Toast a Bagel at All?

Should you toast a bagel? Well, toasting will make the outside crunchy and warm up its center because we all love chewy textures.

Toasting a bagel is an individual decision since it’s up to preference, and there are no right or wrong answers in life.

Toasting a bagel not only makes it less crispy, but also decreases its shelf life.

Bagels are a staple in the breakfast world, but not all of them are created equal. Fresh baked bagel can be enjoyed straight out from oven with no need for toasting it because they already have their signature chewiness just right on chewy!

Let’s face it, bagels from the grocery store are never as good. But if you just brought home a batch of fresh out-of oven baked goodness then there is hope!

You should toast them for best results and get ready to enjoy this classic breakfast food like never before.

You can enjoy delicious bagels by toasting them in a toaster oven or a regular oven.

Why Moisten a Bagel Before Toasting?

When you moisten a bagel before toasting it, you’ll be able to restore it to its original form.

If you have a stale bagel, putting it in water before toasting it could help revive it.

The moisture will evaporate, restoring the crispiness of the bagel’s outside.

Dunking the bagel in a basin of hot water immediately before putting it in the oven is the best method to moisten it. Especially if you’re using a toaster, drain any extra water.

Do I Cut the Bagel Before Toasting?

If you’re toasting the bagel in an oven or toaster oven, toast it whole.

This will ensure that it remains crispy on the surface while being chewy on the inside.

Then, as soon as the bagel is finished cooking, cut it.

If you’re using a toaster, you’ll need to cut the bagel before toasting it to keep it from becoming trapped in the slots.

Can I Toast a Frozen Bagel?

Toasting a frozen bagel is not recommended. Allowing the bagel to thaw before toasting improves the texture significantly.

When microwaved for too long, a bagel turns hard and chewy, but if you’re in a hurry, give a frozen bagel 15 seconds on high, turn, then give it another 15 seconds. Then it’s time to toast.

If you’re in a rush, though, you can toast a frozen bagel. Running the frozen bagel under hot water before toasting it is the best technique to toast it.

How to Revive a Stale Bagel

It’s a shame to get your mouth set for a great bagel breakfast only to find a stale bagel. A hard bagel is such a letdown.

How to revive a stale bagelMoistening a stale bagel is the greatest method to bring it back to life. Allowing it to rest in a basin of water for a minute or two before toasting is an easy method to achieve this.

A stale bagel may also be revived in the microwave oven.

Step 1: Place the bagel on a microwave-safe plate in step one.

Step 2: Wet the plate with a few droplets of water.

Step 3: Microwave on high for 15 seconds after placing the dish in the microwave and covering it with a microwave splatter cover.

Step 4: Give the bagel a once-over.

Step 5: Microwave for an additional 15 seconds.

Note: The microwave splatter cover aids in the softening of the bagel by keeping moisture in and around it.

Instead, a microwave-safe bowl turned upside down may be used to cover the plate.

How to Toast a Bagel in the Oven?

The best method for toasting a bagel in the oven is to roast it whole and then cut it.

To toast the ideal bagel, soak it in warm water for a few minutes before toasting it. This will assist you in recovering that crisp top and lovely chewy inside.

Step 1: Preheat your oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Before you put your bagel in the oven, make sure it’s nice and hot.

Note: Make sure your oven is preheated before moving on to step two.

Step 2: Next, soak your bagel in warm water for a few minutes.

Run the bagel under a stream of hot water from the tap to soften it.

I prefer to boil some water in a bowl and then submerge the bagel in it. Allow one minute for the bagel to soak in the water.

Step 3: Toast the bagel in step three. Place the bagel immediately on the oven’s centre rack.

Note: If you want, you may use a baking sheet instead.

Step 4: Toast the bagel for four minutes in the oven. Check to make sure the bagel is crispy and warm.

You may detect small blisters on the outside of the bagel as a result of moistening it.

This will contribute to the crisp texture that fresh-baked bagels are known for, and it’s an indication that your bagel has been properly toasted.

Step 5: Eat your bagel with a tasty bagel topping.

Learn 4 Amazing Ways to Toast a Bagel Even Without a Toaster

Here are some ways to toast a bagel without using the kitchen appliance known as a toaster. Fold it in half and wait until golden brown on one side before putting it down with butter or margarine for 20 seconds each fold Repeat this process two more times altogether, turning over each time so that all sides have been cooked evenly Serve immediately while hotIf you find yourself at home when someone makes an order of these items but don’t have any toppings available then offer them extra cream cheese instead !!!

1. How to Toast a Bagel on the Stove

  • On the stove, heat a nonstick pan. Now gently and carefully preheat the pan, allowing it to warm for a minute.
  • Cut the bagels in half, and now is the perfect time to butter them.
  • The butter side down is preferred by most people because it allows the butter to properly distribute and absorb into the bagel.
  • Some individuals, on the other hand, like to keep the butter side up since it gives them more time to apply the toppings.
  • Allow it to settle for two minutes. You may close the cover to allow the bagel to toast more quickly.
  • When the bread begins to crisp, quickly flip it over before it burns and toasts the other side.

2. How to Toast Bread in Oven

  • To begin, preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, or 180 degrees Fahrenheit if you want a gentler toasting.
  • Place the bread directly on the centre rack or on a pan.
  • After placing the bread in the oven, keep a close eye on it during the cooking process to avoid scorching your bagel.
  • The bagel will take around 10 minutes to toast. After five minutes, flip it to ensure uniform cooking on both sides.

3. How to Broil Bagel in Oven

  • To begin, check to see if your broiler grill is ready to toast. Preheat the grill for 5-10 minutes before using it.
  • To ensure an equal heat distribution, place the bagel on the rack closest to the topside.
  • A baking sheet can be placed below the bagel to prevent it from plopping down.
  • Maintain a 350°F grill temperature and wait 1-2 minutes for the bagel to finish.

4. How to Toast Bagel over a Campfire

  • To avoid releasing unpleasant components that might make the bagel smell weird, build a campfire on a clean surface.
  • To build the fire, you can use wood chips, logs, or charcoal.
  • Place the grill over the flame after the flames has stabilised to prevent the bagel from slipping.
  • Preheat the grill and place the bagel on it. Butter can also be smeared on the bagel.
  • To toast the bagels correctly, you need check and turn them more frequently; it may even be every few seconds.

What Do You Put on a Bagel?

When you put anything on a bagel, the taste and flavour are amplified by a factor of several. Many individuals, in fact, refuse to consume plain bagels.

Butter or margarine, peanut butter, cream cheese, jam, marshmallow fluff, apple butter, Nutella, cinnamon sugar, and more simple topping options for bagels

You should top your bagel with a protein-rich topping for breakfast. Here are some suggestions:

  • Eggs
  • Cheese and eggs
  • Bacon, cheese, and an egg
  • Egg, cheese, and sausage
  • Egg, cheese, and ham

Lunch and supper menus to consider:

  • Pizza sauce, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese are used to make a pizza.
  • Tuna, mayonnaise, sliced tomato, and cheese
  • Cooked meatball, spaghetti sauce, and mozzarella cheese on a meatball sandwich.
  • Sliced turkey and your preferred cheese on a toasted turkey melt.
  • Cheese with sliced ham.
  • Cucumber and cream cheese are a delicious combination.

3 Key Hacks: Chefs Recommend while Toast a Fresh Bagel

In Case of Fresh Bagels

The most important quality for a fresh bagel is its flavor. Toasting can make you disappointed with the final product, as it will become dry and more difficult to chew on. Chefs recommend that if wanting toast your bread instead because doing so does not affect taste nearly as much!

In Case of Stored Bagels

Bagels are a breakfast staple, but they can be stale and dry. Toasting will improve the taste with an exterior that’s crispy while still being soft inside!

In Case of Toppings

To prevent sogginess of the bagels, you can toast them before loading with toppings or cover and refrigerate for 24 hours.

Can You Toast a Bagel in a Convection Oven?

You certainly can. In a standard oven, toasting bagels is identical to toasting regular bread. To toast a bagel in a convection oven, follow these instructions:

  • Place an oven rack in the oven’s highest position.
  • Preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • Place the bagel pieces on an ungreased baking sheet.
  • Place the sheet in the oven and turn on the broiler.
  • Remove the bagel from the oven as soon as the upper half of the bagel begins to brown.
  • You may butter the untoasted side and top it with a variety of toppings.
  • Place the baking sheet in the convection oven once again and toast the bagel until golden brown.

How to Toast a Bagel in the Oven: A Toaster Oven

To use the bagel feature to toast bagels, you must first slice them. Place them in the middle of the rack now. In the toaster, place the rack. Now you must choose the number of bagel pieces and the toasting intensity. Then press the start button to start toasting.

Set the machine to medium if you’re making a whole wheat bagel. It’s possible that an onion bagel or a cinnamon raisin bagel with extra sugar will be toastier than medium.

Reduce the duration by roughly 20 seconds or lower the machine’s darkness setting to solve this problem.

Toasting A Frozen Bagel

What if you buy bagels in bulk and freeze them so you can enjoy breakfast bagels on weekends? Here are some instructions for toasting a frozen bagel in the oven:

Step 1: Use the bagel function on your oven toaster if it has one.

Step 2: Some oven toasters have clever functions that thaw your bagel automatically and alter the toasting time.

Step 3: If you don’t have this function, simply thaw your bagel in the microwave for 20 seconds before slicing it.

Here are some suggestions for oven toasters without a bagel function:

Step 1: In your oven toaster, use the broil option. The broil mode simulates a ‘bagel’ function by using the upper heating element of your oven toaster.

Step 2: Place the rack in the toaster oven’s centre.

Step 3: Cut your bagel in half and place it on the rack, insides facing up.

Step 4: Broil for 2 to 4 minutes in your toaster oven.

Step 5: The finished bagel will be crisp on the inside and chewy on the outside.

Step 6: To get a crisp bottom on your bagel, simply position it upright in your oven toaster when broiling it.


Bagels are great on the weekends, but you’ll be able to enjoy them even more if your store-bought bagels have been sitting for a few days. Now that I’ve shown how easy it is teach toast these delicious treats in an oven and created some fun recipes with my new found skill (that everyone loves), this will make going out during hectic mornings much easier!

Leave a Comment